稍贵的VPN——ExpressVPN、AstrillVPN、IVPN各方面的比较,都进来说说看

ExpressVPN

expressvpn点com/

Astrill VPN

astrill点com/zh/

IVPN

ivpn点net


看到Astrill VPN的测速很高

astrill点com/zh/network/vpn-speedtest-results

已邀请:

larry 【新手级】 - I'm a network engineer that currently lives in China.

赞同来自: 陀思妥耶夫斯基 khoizhang

Astrill has a really awful private policy. From their official site they state they would collect data such as "connection time", "The original IP address (This one is absurd. Totally inappropriate for any VPN providers)" "Device Type" "App version "
That looks pretty scary but trust me you haven't seen nothing mate. No only they would collect those data but they would also stored it for a period of 30 days. You think that could be the worst. Think again. They also stated that they're able to use these data to "improve" your shopping experiences AKA selling them to the online retailers for profit.

If you think that's the absolute limit oh think again.
They have servers in 64 countries which is fairly good. But they only hold 355 IPs.
355 IPs ??? I'm not joshing anyone here. That's laughable. Like heck by average each location has 5 and half IPs. Nord on the other hand 5400+ IPs in only 54 countries.

Well you think that's the limit now right? All of the flaws have been exposed right?

Well sorry again. Here are more. One of the VPN reviewer has tested their refund policy. And turns out they wouldn't refund you in even 7 days. Yep their refund policy is completely solid, No refunds whatsoever. You can check his review at travelchinacheper.

So yeah. You can choose them If you want. But with this amount of caveats. I wouldn't opt them. But hey I ain't you. So ya think it's worth it then oh well. It's your choice



On the other hand let's talk about IVPN.

They're a fairly small VPN provider. Well not really. They are a puny provider. Most of people haven't even heard them at all. Well they don't really provide service in China. The service is working in China is pretty much a fluke. their policy is solid and also tested by an independent auditor. Which is a really good thing.

Their speed is really average to say the least. It's not good as top level VPN providers. But it's usable.

On the other hand their servers locations are sparse. Only having 225 IPs within 29 countries.It does unlock Netflix but really. That's all the pros there are.

I personally wouldn't recommend it but it's way better than the Astrill imo. And again it's your choice to pick a provider you like.



Astrill有一个非常糟糕的私人政策。他们声明从其官方站点收集诸如“连接时间”,“原始IP地址(这是荒谬的。完全不适合任何VPN提供商)”,“设备类型”,“应用版本”
这看起来很吓人,但请相信我,您还没有看到任何。他们不仅会收集这些数据,而且还会将其存储30天。

您认为那可能是最糟糕的。再想一想。他们还表示,他们能够使用这些数据“改善”您的购物体验,也就是将其出售给在线零售商以获取利润。

如果您认为这是绝对限制,请再考虑一遍。

他们在64个国家/地区拥有服务器,相当不错。但是它们仅拥有355个IP。
355个IP ???我不是在这里打扰任何人。真可笑平均而言,每个位置都有5个IP和一半IP。另一方面,Nord仅在54个国家/地区拥有5400多个IP。

好吧,您认为这是现在的极限了吗?所有的缺陷都暴露出来了吧?


再次抱歉。这里还有更多。 VPN审核员之一已测试了他们的退款政策。事实证明,他们连7天都不会退还您的款项。是的,他们的退款政策是完全可靠的,绝不退款。您可以在travelchinacheper上查看他的评论。

是的。您可以根据需要选择它们。

但是有这么多的警告。我不会选择他们。但是,嘿,我不是你。所以,您认为值得,那就好吧。


选择



另一方面,让我们谈谈IVPN。

他们是相当小的VPN提供商。好吧,不是。他们是一个微不足道的提供者。大多数人甚至根本听不到。好吧,他们实际上并没有在中国提供服务。该服务正在中国运作,这是fl幸。他们的政策是可靠的,并且还经过了独立审核员的测试。真是一件好事。

至少可以说,他们的速度确实是中等的。不能作为顶级VPN提供商。但这是可用的。

另一方面,它们的服务器位置很少。在29个国家/地区只有225个IP。它确实可以解锁Netflix。那就是所有的优点。

我个人不建议这样做,但是它比Astrill imo更好。同样,选择您喜欢的提供者也是您的选择。






Virus 【新手级】 - Network Engineering Expert

赞同来自: ass

Astrill是一家小众公司,Astrill一直致力于为生活和工作在大陆的外国公民提供服务,可能是由于价格昂贵的原因,Astrill的中国人用户并不多。归纳了以下价格昂贵的原因有三点,/1:服务器成本极高,Astrill从不采用虚拟ip的方式,所有的服务器都是原生IP,并且服务器速度非常快,亚洲服务器的带宽成本非常高。Astrill所有服务器都可以直接接入.onion域,无需tor浏览器。/2:Astrill是极少数为中国用户优化线路的供应商,提供了大量的优化线路。用户可以定制多跳式服务器,通过多台服务器代理访问。/3:协议以及客户端支持很全面,Astrill覆盖了几乎所有vpn协议,同时也有自己研制的私有协议,具体可以看官网说明。并且客户端支持所有平台访问,包括linux以及路由器,也可以直接在官网购买路由器使用。

相比之下,ExpressVPN是一家世界知名公司,ExpressVPN的最大优点在于全球服务器的数量与所覆盖的国家特别多,隐私能够得到很大保障,即使在中东,非洲以及南美,Express也部署了大量的服务器,这一点是Astrill完全没法比的,


yyq1991 【新手级】

赞同来自: khoizhang

我用过速度真的快的vpn就是express ,当然不是指现在。其实我也没怎么研究,月付过astrill,龟速。可能是因为当时express太无脑了,根本不需要去考虑其他的,以前express idm满线程20m/s,几个月下了几百t资源就是靠它,现在偶尔用用,速度慢链接难,下载不要想,看看网页还行。估计现在也没有适合大量下载的vpn了,不大量下载其实真没什么的,随便用

Jason_Fue 【熟练级】 - VPN enthusiastist

Astrill那个都是本地测速吧,如果在中国测延迟几乎不可能低于35ms(以Rackspace提供的HK3为例),所以我个人认为他们官网的测速对于我们并没有参考价值。虽然我没用过Astrill但他们既然敢这样定价那质量应该不错。

khoizhang 【新手级】

Express连接非常痛苦,经常要连好几次,有时候连上了速度也不稳定;


Astrill和Ivpn都有wireguard协议,连接和速度肯定飞快;


但最关键的不是这些,而是express用户太多,又被针对;后两者几乎不会被针对。

RIP 【新手级】 - RIP=run into problem

我倒是想换到Astrill的但是。。。expressvpn已经很贵了钱包不允许我这样

hey 【新手级】

有人用过说说看。


fuckccp 【新手级】

Mullvad說它們有提供ipv6的通道, 效果怎樣?

要回复问题请先登录注册